This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
A classic recipe for burnt chocolate chip cookies calls for adding extra vanilla extract to the dough. However, when adding the extra vanilla extract to the dough, the cookies can quickly go from delicious to completely unappealing.
In these situations, you can use a zester or a cheese grater to remove the extra vanilla from the dough, or you can simply add artificial vanilla extract instead. Whatever you do, make sure that you have the right tools to prevent a burnt cookie.
Using a zester
A citrus lemon will add an extra punch to these classic cookie recipes. Fresh lemon zest or juice will improve the flavor of your baked goods, and you can use store-bought lemon curd to make lemon cookies. Prepare your baking sheets by lining them with parchment paper or spraying them with non-stick cooking spray. To make these cookies, combine butter, sugar, and eggs until they are soft and well-combined. Add lemon zest and gently toss each cookie dough ball in the sugar mixture, separating them by three inches.
For a more convenient method, you can use a cheese grater or a regular knife. Slice the burnt portions away using the knife’s blade. If it’s too hard or the cookies are too soft, you can use a butter knife to scrape out the burnt bits. Once you’ve scraped away the burned parts, place the cookies in an airtight container. You can also use a slice of bread to soften them.
If your citrus-flavored baked goods aren’t as vibrant as you’d like, you can substitute orange juice for it. Citrus juice adds a tart, acidic flavor. While citrus juice does change the chemistry of baked goods, citrus zest adds a fresh, zesty taste to baked goods. Moreover, citrus zester tools are ergonomically designed to make them easy to use.
If you don’t have a citrus juicer, you can still use a box grater. You can use the small holes of the grater to scrape the burnt portions away. It will take a bit of practice, but the end result will be worth it. If you’re a baking novice, using a zester to zest burnt chocolate chip cookies is worth it.
Sugar-based baked goods are a recipe’s biggest flaw. The sugar helps baked goods spread and brown. If the sugar content is reduced too much, the cookies will be puffy. To avoid this, simply remove the excess sugar. After that, sift the remaining flour and baking soda into the mixer bowl. Then add the orange zest. The mixture should be beaten on medium-high for a few minutes until it’s well-combined.
Using a cheese grater
Using a cheese grater to scrape away burned chocolate chip cookies is a great way to salvage a partially-baked batch. If you’re working with a small cookie, a hand grater may be sufficient. However, for larger burnt cookies, a serrated knife is a better option. It will remove the entire bottom of the cookie as well as any other burned parts.
If you don’t have a cheese grater, you can use a microplaner to quickly remove charred bits from the bottom of a cookie. Microplaners can also be used to zest lemon and other citrus fruits, which are good for scraping burnt chocolate chip cookies. If you’re working with a cookie that’s too small to fit into a microplaner, you can tilt the cookie in order to press it into the planer.
You can also use a cheese grater to scrape burned bottoms from chocolate chip cookies, so that they’re less ugly and more fudgy. You can also use a plastic knife or a zester to slice a cake. But make sure to work slowly and carefully so you don’t ruin the cookie. Otherwise, you’ll end up with a cake that’s much too thin, despite its appearance.
You can also try covering the burnt part with a layer of melted chocolate or candy melts. This will cover the burnt area and conceal it from view. Another good option for a burnt cookie is a cookie sandwich. In this way, the burned part will be hidden and the whole cookie will still be edible. A few minutes of effort can make the entire cookie look better than before.
The cookie should be completely cool before you begin scraping it off. The brown color should be evenly distributed and not burnt. This can take some time, so you should work slowly to get the best results. You can also apply the brown color to the sides of the cookie, where the burned parts are. The sides will still look a little dirty. If the edges are black, then these are dirty and need to be scraped off.
Using a nonstick baking sheet
Using a parchment paper lined nonstick baking sheet makes it much easier to remove baked cookies, and the sheet is easy to clean. It’s also convenient to have an extra sheet handy, so you can scoop extra batches while your first batch is baking, and slide it in the oven when you’re done. However, make sure you restock your cookie sheet after baking several batches, as parchment paper will start to get messy over time.
You can also use a tin-lined copper baking sheet. Copper conducts heat and prevents the food from burning and overcooking. The copper lining will also help prevent cookies from catching fire, so you’ll avoid burnt edges and bottoms. Using a tin-lined copper baking sheet can also help you to avoid the dreaded burnt cookie dilemma.
Another option is to scrub the baking sheet with baking soda or hydrogen peroxide. A mixture of one part hydrogen peroxide to three parts baking soda can work well to remove baked-on stains. Make sure to leave the baking sheet in this solution for fifteen to thirty minutes before washing. This can encourage the food particles to fall off more easily. If you have non-stick baking sheets, this method can be very useful for your oven.
When choosing a nonstick baking sheet, make sure that it is light-colored. A dark color will absorb heat and cause the cookies to burn on the bottom. Light-colored sheets are also better for baking cookies because they are more likely to stick to the surface. You can also line the sheet with parchment paper to make sure that the cookies don’t stick. If you’re unsure, make sure to try different colors.
Another option is to use a silicone pan instead of a non-stick baking sheet. Non-stick pans are made of inexpensive metals and won’t cause food to stick. As a bonus, these sheets can be washed with warm water, air dried, and even put in the dishwasher. It’s a no-brainer, especially when you’re trying to avoid burnt chocolate chip cookies!
Using artificial vanilla
Despite its name, using artificial vanilla to make burnt chocolate chip cookies may be a mistake that you must avoid. Using the wrong flavoring can result in under or over-baked cookies. The problem might be that artificial vanilla tends to have a stronger flavor. To solve this problem, try substituting 2 tbsp corn syrup. This will make the cookie dough slightly more manageable and help prevent burnt cookies.
For the best results, use fresh ingredients whenever possible. If the vanilla you’re using is past its prime, your cookies will turn out bitter. To avoid this, use a quality vanilla extract. In some cases, using artificial vanilla will also cause the cookies to be bland and taste artificial. When preparing your cookies, be sure to measure them carefully. Use a glass or see-through plastic measuring cup to measure liquids. Make sure to spray or oil your measuring cups. Don’t set the rack too high in your oven, as this will result in burnt cookies. Also, avoid sneaking the dough into the oven; this will shorten the baking time and may make you sick.
If you don’t want to use artificial vanilla, you can substitute bergamot oil. This substitute is more flavorful than vanilla extract, but it won’t taste as good. In fact, bergamot oil is an orange oil used to flavor Earl Grey tea. You can also substitute it for 2 teaspoons of pure vanilla extract. When you use this substitute, the cookies will be more flavorful than those that contain artificial vanilla.
While most traditional recipes start with the same ingredients and methods, artificial vanilla may result in burnt chocolate chip cookies. To prevent burnt chocolate chip cookies, make sure to use real butter, a splash of milk, and extra vanilla extract. If desired, add chopped nuts or M&Ms to the cookie dough. Then, bake the cookies for 8-10 minutes. The cookies will continue to cook after being removed from the oven.